Page 1 of 1
Bishop cam
Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2005 5:47 pm
by Terry Horlick
A while ago (nearly a month)I got my car to the point I could test
it up to speed on the freeway. When I got home the steering broke.
I posted photos of the broken sector but, as Bob pointed out, I
didn't make a lot of my suspicions that the car had been in a
collision in the dim past.
While my photos indeed show how and where the sector can break, it
didn't show what type of force was required to do it. The car has a
replacement right front wing and as I removed the steering box for
repair I found that the damage was not just to the sector. By
withdrawing the shaft I found shards of the shattered thrust washer
from the Tompkins kit. Once the box was removed from the car it
became evident that inboard arm of the cast steel mounting bracket
had been snapped off. It definitely takes more than a pothole to do
that kind of damage.
I had an opportunity to purchase a Datsun box ready for installation
but upon discussion with Bob Grunau I decided to repair the original
steering. There are instructions on some websites on proper set-up
of the Bishop box, these are easy to follow. I found that my box
had just the proper set-up and perfect number of shims, so the cause
of the damage and sloppy steering must have been the collision.
Today I put the car back together and went for a ride. With the
bracket welded up and the sector replaced, everything set up
properly there is no play in the steering wheel, no effort is needed
to steer. It is now easy to turn all the way to both locks. You
can go down the freeway and feel comfortable with one finger on the
wheel... in fact I took both hands off the wheel and the car just
kept on straight ahead just like a modern car... except with more
style!
The folks who write on the web about restoring the stock steering
are right, there really doesn't seem to be any reason to goober up
the car with non-original parts. The repair on the original is easy
and it really only takes minutes to pull the whole steering assembly
out of the car or to put it back in. The design of the whole thing
seems to have been planned out so that a home tinkerer can do
everything with hand tools. As a modern seal had already been
installed in my box I didn't even get to use my lathe or mill!
Notice that I had a really scary steering failure, but after
evaluating the design and the parts I am really confident
that this steering set-up is safe and up to any demand I might ever
place on the car. It is also interesting to note that you can slam
these cars hard enough to break the steering brackets, sectors, and
thrust washers... but the car just keeps on going; the previous
owner didn't even know (or admit?) the damage was in there!
Safety fast?.... yup!
Terry TC2285
Re: Bishop cam
Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2005 9:51 pm
by Rick Waters
I am another one pleased with the original steering. I've put in a lip seal and a Tomkins kit, but the box, which i rebuilt, is otherwise stock.
I am curious as to how big and strong your finger is, as I have never heard anybody describe the stock steering, even with the Tompkins (SP?) kit! My kingpins, thrust washers, and steering ball joints are all like new, and the car does not wander, but, it does NOT have light steering.
On another note, I was given a spare steering box by a former TC owner, who swore that it worked when it was taken out of his TC and replaced with a newer one. He said it had not been taken apart, just put away in his garage. When I took it apart, there was no worm shaft bearing on the bottom of the worm! I wonder how that car steered!
-Rick
Terry Horlick thorlick@sbcglobal.net> wrote:
A while ago (nearly a month)I got my car to the point I could test
it up to speed on the freeway. When I got home the steering broke.
I posted photos of the broken sector but, as Bob pointed out, I
didn't make a lot of my suspicions that the car had been in a
collision in the dim past.
While my photos indeed show how and where the sector can break, it
didn't show what type of force was required to do it. The car has a
replacement right front wing and as I removed the steering box for
repair I found that the damage was not just to the sector. By
withdrawing the shaft I found shards of the shattered thrust washer
from the Tompkins kit. Once the box was removed from the car it
became evident that inboard arm of the cast steel mounting bracket
had been snapped off. It definitely takes more than a pothole to do
that kind of damage.
I had an opportunity to purchase a Datsun box ready for installation
but upon discussion with Bob Grunau I decided to repair the original
steering. There are instructions on some websites on proper set-up
of the Bishop box, these are easy to follow. I found that my box
had just the proper set-up and perfect number of shims, so the cause
of the damage and sloppy steering must have been the collision.
Today I put the car back together and went for a ride. With the
bracket welded up and the sector replaced, everything set up
properly there is no play in the steering wheel, no effort is needed
to steer. It is now easy to turn all the way to both locks. You
can go down the freeway and feel comfortable with one finger on the
wheel... in fact I took both hands off the wheel and the car just
kept on straight ahead just like a modern car... except with more
style!
The folks who write on the web about restoring the stock steering
are right, there really doesn't seem to be any reason to goober up
the car with non-original parts. The repair on the original is easy
and it really only takes minutes to pull the whole steering assembly
out of the car or to put it back in. The design of the whole thing
seems to have been planned out so that a home tinkerer can do
everything with hand tools. As a modern seal had already been
installed in my box I didn't even get to use my lathe or mill!
Notice that I had a really scary steering failure, but after
evaluating the design and the parts I am really confident
that this steering set-up is safe and up to any demand I might ever
place on the car. It is also interesting to note that you can slam
these cars hard enough to break the steering brackets, sectors, and
thrust washers... but the car just keeps on going; the previous
owner didn't even know (or admit?) the damage was in there!
Safety fast?.... yup!
Terry TC2285
Yahoo! Groups Links
-Rick Waters
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Re: Bishop cam
Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2005 10:51 am
by Jorolibb@aol.com
Terry,
What websites show how to set up a Bishop Cam box are you referring to?
Thanks,
John Libbert
Milford, OH
TC 2138
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Re: Bishop cam
Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2005 12:48 pm
by Terry Horlick
John,
There are several. First read through the old MG service
information found in the manuals. Then check out the web.
two links require you sign on to the t-abc list at
http://www.mg-tabc.org/
http://www.mg-tabc.org/techn-up/bishop-cam.htm
This is a link to an old article which you can download and read.
http://www.mg-tabc.org/files/buell-tc-frontend.pdf
This is an excellent article on the full front end set-up, a must-
read.
http://www.mg-tabc.org/files/buell-tc-frontend.pdf
This is the best one for setting up your original box in my
opinion. I suggest you downloak it and print it out then put it in
your three ring binder of collected repair-maintenance tips (you are
compiling one of these, right?).
If you run into problems contact some of the folks on-line on this
list (not me, but someone who has lots of experience).
Terry
--- In
mg-tabc@yahoogroups.com, Jorolibb@a... wrote:
> Terry,
>
> What websites show how to set up a Bishop Cam box are you
referring to?
>
> Thanks,
>
> John Libbert
> Milford, OH
> TC 2138
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Bishop Cam
Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 1:30 pm
by Peter Roberts
Here is a puzzler for you all.
I am about to replace the cam at the end of the steering shaft. Doug Pelton has kindly sent me an article detailing how this is to be done. Step one is, obviously, to remove the old cam. And step two is to install the new cam. However, the article cautions as follows:
Before removing the old cam make a note of the top and bottom and ensure that the new cam goes on the same way around.
Ok, but suppose the old cam was put on backwards. How will you know if you have your new cam the right way around? Do anyone have a clue on how to verify the topness and bottomness of the Bishop Cam?
Many thanks in advance,
_Peter in CT
TC0604
Re: Bishop Cam
Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 2:15 pm
by Madhu Paroor
Hi Peter,
I will make sure that both end stoppers are in place and are similar. Then I will start from one end and insert the old arm. before tightening it, check the steering position. Make sure that that the steering is in the middle is wheels are straight.If everything is in good position, one can start tightening.
Just a stupid thought. Those members with more experience will have better idea.
TC 0448 original box has very little wear and very little play. So no experience in steering fiddling.
madhu
2013/1/10 Peter Roberts mgtc@comcast.net>
[u][/u]
Here is a puzzler for you all. I am about to replace the cam at the end of the steering shaft. Doug Pelton has kindly sent me an article detailing how this is to be done. Step one is, obviously, to remove the old cam. And step two is to install the new cam. However, the article cautions as follows: Before removing the old cam make a note of the top and bottom and ensure that the new cam goes on the same way around. Ok, but suppose the old cam was put on backwards. How will you know if you have your new cam the right way around? Do anyone have a clue on how to verify the topness and bottomness of the Bishop Cam? Many thanks in advance, _Peter in CT TC0604
Re: Bishop Cam
Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 4:01 pm
by Peter Roberts
What a marvelous group we have to find such an esoteric tidbit as this! Bob, I immediately went and looked at the new Cam and it most assuredly has a spline at one end and a smooth bore at the other! I assume that the inner column is similarly fitted out with a smooth shaft at the end leading up to some splining where the Cam splines engage. No doubt this will become quite clear when I remove the old Cam. Thanks so much for your assist! _Peter [b]From:[/b]
grunau.garage@sympatico.ca [b]Sent:[/b] Thursday, January 10, 2013 4:52 PM [b]To:[/b]
mgtc@comcast.net [b]Subject:[/b] RE: [mg-tabc] Bishop Cam Peter, there is an inner spline on the steering cam. This will be at the FORWARD end of the cam ane inner column. Heat the end of the inner steering shaft where it is peened over, drift out the old cam. Install new cam with inner splines forward, or to forward end of inner column. heat column end and peen over to hold the cam in place. Bob Grunau
[quote] -----Original Message-----
[b]From:[/b]
mg-tabc@yahoogroups.com [mailto:
mg-tabc@yahoogroups.com][b]On Behalf Of [/b]Peter Roberts
[b]Sent:[/b] Thursday, January 10, 2013 4:31 PM
[b]To:[/b]
mg-tabc@yahoogroups.com
[b]Subject:[/b] [mg-tabc] Bishop Cam
Here is a puzzler for you all. I am about to replace the cam at the end of the steering shaft. Doug Pelton has kindly sent me an article detailing how this is to be done. Step one is, obviously, to remove the old cam. And step two is to install the new cam. However, the article cautions as follows: Before removing the old cam make a note of the top and bottom and ensure that the new cam goes on the same way around. Ok, but suppose the old cam was put on backwards. How will you know if you have your new cam the right way around? Do anyone have a clue on how to verify the topness and bottomness of the Bishop Cam? Many thanks in advance, _Peter in CT TC0604
[/quote]