oils are or ain't oils?
Posted: Sat Dec 16, 2006 9:23 pm
I have an '05 KLR650 bought new in Feb 06. After paying A$288
(US$225)for its first, 1000km dealer service, which consisted only of
oil + filter change and probably cleaning the air filter**, I have
decided to do future servicing myself. The dealer said that they'd
filled with synthetic oil, but did not specify which type. I now want
some advice on the oil to use.
[** Dealer had apprentice wash the dust off the bike, which I did not
want or authorize, but he didn't wash the dust off under the left side
cover, so I could see that battery levels were not checked, nor was
tank removed to inspect anything under there, like the spark plug.
Etc. I didn't get $225 worth of work & materials!]
On previous bikes, all air-cooled, I've always used "mineral" oils
(should be called "natural mineral oils", vs "re-synthesized" oils,
since the stuff in both originally comes from holes in the ground),
but it seems that the "synthetics" really are a technical advance, so
I'd like to go with these.
I've done a little Googling, and it seems that the API grades
specified for the KLR by Kawasaki are obsolete, dating from the time
of the original KL/KLR design and the era of mineral-only oils. See
table at http://www.carbibles.com/engineoil_bible.html . This table
says that API SE, SF, SG and SH are obsolete, and that SJ is nearly
obsolete. That covers Kawi's entire recommended range!! The table
says that API SM and SL are "For all automotive engines presently in
use." As far as I'm concerned, that includes motorcycles, especially
water-cooled ones. BUT, there may be a complication if there are
FRICTION-MODIFIERS in the oils, which could cause a WET CLUTCH to SLIP.
----------------------
QUESTION: Has anyone out there tried any of the SM or SL synthetic
oils that are marketed with cars in mind, rather than motorcycles, in
their KLR or other wet-clutch bike? Any clutch problems?
-----------------------
Sure, I can go to a bike shop and get a "motorcycle" oil. However,
these may not be the latest and greatest oils. For example, Castrol's
website recommends their GTS or R4 oils, which are both to the
nearly-obsolete SG rating. Can I use their GTX3 (car) synthetic, for
example?
PS: I'm in Australia, where we have oils from mainstream companies
such as Castrol, Shell, Mobil, BP, locally-refined Valvoline, as well
as others, but some US others may not be as readily available.
And Seasons Greetings to you all
- Richard - Sydney, AUS