Page 1 of 1
click but no whir-means relay is good or bad?
Posted: Fri Apr 30, 2004 4:44 pm
by George Sinchent Quinby Adams
I used the earlier advice (thanks all) to try and find out why my fan
would not come on (or only occasionally when hitting a large bump)
and when I short the heat sensor from the bottom of the radiator to
the frame I hear a distinct "click" of I guess it is the relay.
But sadly no nice whir of fan. Fan will work if power is applied to
it directly however.
Does this mean the relay is shot?
Is it common and are they expensive?
Why does it need a relay, and what does a relay really do?
click but no whir-means relay is good or bad?
Posted: Fri Apr 30, 2004 6:05 pm
by Eric L. Green
On Fri, 30 Apr 2004, George Sinchent Quinby Adams wrote:
> Why does it need a relay, and what does a relay really do?
A relay allows taking a small current, like from a temperature sensor, and
use it to switch a bigger current, like a fan motor. You can go down to
Radio Shack and look at transparent ones to see how that works. The small
current goes through a wire wrapped around a piece of iron. When current
flows, the iron becomes magnetized, and pulls down a flexible piece of
metal (hooked to the fusebox and thus to the battery) to touch a contact
(hooked to the fan). When the flexible piece meets the contact, current
flows, turning on the fan.
The usual failure mode for a relay is that either one of the wires to foil
or contact go bad, or the contact burns off due to fluctuating current in
the magnet (such as might happen with a bad sensor) causing it to
repeatedly arc. You can replace a relay either with the specific relay or
with a generic one. When the horn relay went out on my mother's 1982 Honda
Civic, Honda wanted $50 for a new one. I went down to Radio Shack, bought
a generic 12 volt relay for $5, wired it in and RTV'ed the thing to keep
water out of it, and it worked fine until she dumped the Civic in 1992.
The advantage of an automotive-quality relay is that it's typically more
robust than a Radio Shack quality relay. Also note that you have to do
some current matching here -- a relay that requires more current to
activate its coil than is put out by the temperature sensor is going to
burn out the temperature sensor. So while that horn relay was fine for
what I did with it, you probably want to at least put an automotive
quality relay with the right current rating for this application, if you
don't put the "real" (official Kawasaki) relay on there.
-E
click but no whir-means relay is good or bad?
Posted: Fri Apr 30, 2004 8:21 pm
by hijklr
George,
What year is your KLR? A dealer had to replace the thermo
fan switch and relay on my A17 under warranty at 5800 miles
because the fan quit. They lost (denied ever seeing it) the KLR
harness for the wolfman tankbag. I was able to get the fan
spinning by grounding the switch lead but dealer said they
couldn't. Half the pleasure of owning a KLR is being able to
work on it with the help of others. May the KLR live.
Kevin
click but no whir-means relay is good or bad?
Posted: Fri Apr 30, 2004 9:09 pm
by George Sinchent Quinby Adams
Eeny meeny miney mo....um A13...hey I'm catching on (even if I had
to use my fingers to count)
In other words, in laymans terms mine is a '99
Hopefully this weekend I'll have time to get to the bottom of this
(and maybe to the bottom of a brew or two)
--- In
DSN_klr650@yahoogroups.com, "hijklr" wrote:
> George,
> What year is your KLR? A dealer had to replace the thermo
> fan switch and relay on my A17 under warranty at 5800 miles
> because the fan quit. They lost (denied ever seeing it) the KLR
> harness for the wolfman tankbag. I was able to get the fan
> spinning by grounding the switch lead but dealer said they
> couldn't. Half the pleasure of owning a KLR is being able to
> work on it with the help of others. May the KLR live.
> Kevin
klr @ guzzi rally
Posted: Sat May 01, 2004 1:39 am
by joesal9
On the way down to the Guzzi Rally, I/we ran into Todd Rumps with Happy
Trails Products during a fuel stop. They have some sweet gear for the KLR...
The various gaurds have a factory-fit. Definitely worth a look, if you haven't
already.
Sal
KLR A9
Connie A19